Forest Plan Report Finds Fire Is Old Growth’s Biggest Enemy

A new report from researchers at the U.S. Forest Service has found that the Northwest Forest Plan has shifted the threat to old-growth forests. Central Oregon correspondent Ethan Lindsey reports.


Used to be, loggers were the biggest threat to old-growth forest habitat in Oregon and the Northwest.

But, now it's 14 years since the passage of the NW Forest Plan.  And a study published this month in the journal Ecosystems finds that wildfires take down more of the precious old-growth annually than do chain saws.

Researchers say forest policy needs to better address the threat of wildfires by thinning and other methods.

Timber industry consultant Chuck Burley says that's obvious.

Chuck Burley: “Any of us that live in this central Oregon area, we didn’t need the Pacific Northwest Research Station to tell us that, because every fire they’ve had on the Sisters Ranger District has burnt up many, many square miles of old-growth forests.”

Environmentalists say they aren’t against thinning as a concept but that a lot of the time, loggers use thinning as an excuse to clearcut more old-growth.

Comments

November 12, 2008
3:42 p.m.
It would be nice of someone would read the study before mis-reporting the findings, or letting the timber industry mis-represent the facts once again. This study actually found logging removed more old forest than fire in twice as many eco-provinces (6) compared to 3 eco-provinces in which fire removed more old forest than logging. And in total, logging is still by far the bigger threat. Also, fire is a natural ecological process and does not destroy forest the way logging and logging roads do. So this news story reports on the minority conclusion and ignores the majority conclusion. Other reports show that in the decade following the Northwest Forest Plan fire removed 141,000 acres of old forest, logging on federal land removed 156,000 acres, and logging on non-federal land (mostly private industrial forests) removed 583,000 acres of old forest. NOW THAT'S NEWS! See http://dl-client.getdropbox.com/u/47741/%21Non-federal%20owl%20habitat%20loss.doc

— Posted by dougoh

November 12, 2008
3:53 p.m.
Shocking that the Forest Service (read: Bush administration) says logging isn't the biggest threat to old-growth forests. If their plans for western Oregon BLM lands(WOPR) goes through, the chain saws will once again be the biggest threat to old-growth forests. The main problem here is that old-growth forests that burn continue to provide habitat and soil stability for years to come. Old-growth forests that are logged provide nothing and release way more CO2 into the atmosphere than a fire. Sad to see OPB being spoon fed a slanted report by the Bush administration - especially considering how much credibility it has on environmental issues. Pearcy

— Posted by Pearcy


Post a Comment

You must be logged in to post.

Login or register to set up an account.

© 2007, Oregon Public Broadcasting.

Search · Inside OPB · Report Reception Problems · Privacy Policy · Terms of Use · Contact Us · Pressroom · Employment · Community · Audio Streams · RSS Feeds


PBSNPRPRIBBC